The Right to Be (Kind of) Even ?
First a little bit of back story…
This topic/situation came up today as my two fellow EqDeriv interns (Vlad from Carnegie Mellon and Matt from Penn State) and I were stuck in an empty office while our desks were being used/moved around. We originally started talking about the 2nd Amendment and how Matt and I (he’s a conservo-tarian like myself) would like to go to a shooting range before the summer is over. Vlad, while admitting he would not want to deprive everyone of the lawful right to own a fire arm, was a little more skeptical on the subject of the 2nd amendment - he was unfortunately harping on the usual “gun control” talking points of “protecting” small children, people bringing concealed guns to bars and getting drunk and shooting people and criminals having an easier chance to kill you if you draw a weapon (all of which I strongly disagree with, but that’s neither here nor there).
Anyway, I brought up the point of being safe in one’s home. I firmly believe that a man (or woman’s) home is his castle and he has every right to defend it with deadly force if necessary. I explained to Vlad (while Matt agreed and tried to further convince him) that I would like to own a gun and learn to use it properly so that, God forbid, if I ever had to use it to defend myself or my family, that I would not hesitate and pull the trigger. He was still a little skeptical on the whole issue (he thought if you pulled a gun on a robber in your home you would be more at risk to being shot yourself), so I brought up the following slightly related situation…
In the light of the terrorist bombings in London, the MTA decides to allow commuters on the Long Island Rail Road to carry concealed hand guns. You would be required to go through stringent background checks and complete a qualification course, but if you fit the requirements and passed the screenings, you could carry on a LIRR train. This is purely hypothetical of couse, because this situation would also have to involve NYC allowing concealed handguns to be legal, which has about as much of a chance of happening as say, the City Council having a Republican majority next year.
With that background in mind, you pass the required federal background screenings, shoot a pefect qualifying test, and decide to carry your small .45 Glock in a hidden inside pocket of your briefcase for your ride on the LIRR. Obviously not everyone will be carrying on the train, but given the times you could imagine that more then one person probably is.
After a long day at work you crack open that bottle of Diet Coke and sit back on your aisle seat hoping that the woman sitting next to you with three suitcases piled into the overhead rack won’t have to change trains at Jamaica. About midway through the tunnel under the East River you notice an Middle Eastern man about six rows infont of you stand up and reach for his back pack in the overhead rack. Giving the times your curiosity perks up and you glance up from your NY Post at him. He takes his bag down and returns to his seat. Satisfied and eager to return to your crossword puzzle you break off your concerned glances and dive back into your paper. A nagging feeling pops into your head and you, as almost an unfelt reflex, move your briefcase from its position inbetween you and Mrs. Three Suitcases and onto your lap where you have quicker access to Mr. 45 in his secret compartment. Two minutes later that same Middle Eastern man stands up again, this time wearing a vest covered in plastique explosives, holding a wired detonator, and screaming something murderous in Arabic. Fully alert now, and happy that his back is still to you, your hand reaches into that secret compartment of your briefcase and you carefully and slowly retrieve your hidden handgun.
The terrorist is standing with a vest-ful of high explosives in the middle of a crowded commuter train racing under the East River with his back to you and you are holding a loaded handgun unbeknownst to him. He is at most 10 feet away from you and there are no obstructions - no one is getting up to challenge him, hell people further away can’t even see what’s going on yet. You have no idea if there are more terrorists in the other cars of the train or if this guy is a solo artist. Cell phones do not work in this tunnel so calling for help is truly not an option. The MTA never had planned to put police or armed guards on every train so you are obviously alone right now. What do you do?